Greatest Scarlett Johansson Movies of All Time
Lucy or Her

Pick Your Favorite

LUCY

VS

HER
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Isn't it fascinating how Scarlett Johansson's 'Lucy' and 'Her' stand as testaments to the diverse tapestry of human (and post-human) experience? In 'Lucy,' we witness the raw, explosive evolution of mankind's potential, a narrative bursting with action and philosophical ponderings. Contrast this with the introspective, tender solitude of 'Her,' where the complexities of love and artificial intelligence are explored with quiet intensity. This battle isn’t just about which film ranks higher; it’s about what resonates deeper with us—unbridled human advancement or the nuanced corridors of the heart. Which values do we champion as viewers, the visceral or the existential?

🔥 Fan Takes

Honestly, why argue? Both movies show different facets of Scarlett's talent. Can't we just enjoy both?
lucy was fun but her made me feel stuff fr, was like falling into a tech-love abyss or something, can't even explain...
Her all the way, bro. Lucy’s cool, but where’s the depth? 🤷‍♂️

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.

Fan FAQs

What makes Her so popular among Scarlett Johansson fans?

Her stands out for Scarlett’s voice role, which many fans find deeply moving. Her ability to express a wide range of emotions purely through her voice, creating a tangible and heart-wrenching relationship without ever appearing on screen, resonates strongly with those who value nuanced storytelling.

What’s the appeal of Lucy in the Greatest Scarlett Johansson Movies League?

Fans love Lucy for its intense action and Scarlett's role as a powerhouse lead. The film's blend of sci-fi and thriller elements with Johansson's performance as a woman transforming into a superhuman really captivates audiences who favor adrenaline-pumping scenes.

Why is the matchup between Lucy and Her so tight in the Scarlett Johansson Movies League?

It's neck and neck because both movies showcase Scarlett Johansson's range brilliantly but in very different ways. Lucy offers high-octane action, while Her delivers a deeply emotional experience. Fans are split based on what resonates more with them: visceral thrill or emotional depth.