Two picks. One winner. No fence-sitting.
The battle between New Haven (Apizza) and St. Louis-Style Pizza cuts deep into the crust of America's pizza soul, each flaunting a radically unique approach to this beloved dish. New Haven keeps it traditional with its charred, crunchy crust and minimalist toppings, demanding respect for its purist methodologies. In contrast, St. Louis goes bold with a thin, cracker-like crust and a sweet sauce, topped extravagantly with Provel cheese, challenging the very definition of pizza. As these two titans tie in fan votes, the heat only escalates—will tradition triumph, or will innovation reign supreme? Cast your vote and let your taste buds be heard!
| Criteria | Edge | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Crust Game | New Haven (Apizza) | New Haven's crust strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crispy, outdoing the cracker-thin crust of St. Louis. |
| Crave Factor | New Haven (Apizza) | New Haven's rich flavors and hearty texture have undeniable pull, making it more crave-worthy. |
| Pizza Night Vibes | New Haven (Apizza) | For an iconic pizza night, New Haven's rustic charm and satisfying slices set the right tone. |
| Heat Level | St. Louis-Style Pizza | St. Louis-style pizza advocates are fervently loyal, often defending their unique use of Provel cheese in heated debates. |
Latest battle odds:
St. Louis-Style Pizza: 69%
New Haven (Apizza): 31%
Overall battle results:
Overall fans prefer St. Louis-Style Pizza over New Haven (Apizza) when it comes to the greatest Pizza Styles of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick St. Louis-Style Pizza 87.0% of the time over New Haven (Apizza).
Across all battles:
St. Louis-Style Pizza win rate: 51.0%
New Haven (Apizza) win rate: 27.0%
This debate is heated because you’ve got the classic, beloved St. Louis-Style with its own loyal fanbase vs. the artisanal charm of New Haven (Apizza). It's like choosing between nostalgia and culinary prestige! The GOAT List for Greatest Pizza Styles of All Time shows where everyone else lands.
New Haven (Apizza) has that distinct charred crust and fresh toppings that just hit different. Plus, the love for its traditional preparation style creates a deep emotional connection for many pizza lovers.
Fans are rallying behind St. Louis-Style Pizza because of its unique thin crust and that gooey Provel cheese that sparks such nostalgic vibes. A lot of people remember childhood memories tied to this pizza, giving it a major fan-fueled momentum.