Metroid vs Super Mario Bros.
Super Mario Bros. leads with 90% of votes
Latest odds: Super Mario Bros. - 80%, Metroid - 20%
Metroid = Pioneered non-linear gameplay
Super Mario Bros. = Iconic, industry-reviving platformer
See full Original NES Game rankings →Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
The Real Debate
Metroid plunges players into a dense, dark sci-fi universe, while Super Mario Bros. delivers a bright, whimsical fantasy world. This battle isn't just about what defines an iconic NES game, it's a clash of atmospheres and legacies with fans fiercely defending their favorite. On one side, the eerie and explorative depths of Metroid challenge gamers who crave rich, narrative-driven experiences. On the other, the cheerful, straightforward platforming of Mario has charmed countless players with its simplicity and joy. Which classic holds your allegiance? Dive in and decide which legacy you champion!
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Criteria | Edge | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Gameplay Innovation | Metroid | Metroid introduced non-linear exploration and backtracking, which was revolutionary compared to the linear, level-by-level progression of Super Mario Bros. |
| Graphics and Design | Super Mario Bros. | Super Mario Bros.' bright, distinct levels and character designs set the visual standard for future platformers and are instantly recognizable. |
| Soundtrack Quality | Super Mario Bros. | The Super Mario Bros. theme is one of the most iconic video game tracks ever, instantly recognizable and endlessly covered. |
| Cultural Impact | Super Mario Bros. | Super Mario Bros. is arguably the single most influential video game of all time, credited with reviving the video game industry during the 1980s. |
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
Latest battle odds:
Super Mario Bros.: 80%
Metroid: 20%
Overall battle results:
Overall fans prefer Super Mario Bros. over Metroid when it comes to the greatest Original NES Games of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Super Mario Bros. 90.5% of the time over Metroid.
Across all battles:
Super Mario Bros. win rate: 83.2%
Metroid win rate: 39.9%
Fan FAQs
Why is this Metroid vs. Super Mario Bros. matchup such a hot topic?
This debate gets people fired up because you’ve got classic adventure versus platforming legacy! Fans are pretty split, with some loving the deep exploration of Metroid while others can't resist the charm and simplicity of Mario.
What makes Metroid such a beloved contender?
Metroid's mix of atmosphere, exploration, and that iconic female protagonist, Samus, strikes a chord with fans. The game just has this mysterious quality that bonds players to its universe, making it super special.
Why is Super Mario Bros. winning by so much?
Fans are just swept away by the nostalgia of Mario's adventures; he's like the face of gaming for a whole generation! Plus, the impact of the game on pop culture keeps new fans coming in, making it hard for Metroid to catch up.