Metroid vs Super Mario Bros.
Super Mario Bros. leads with 92% of votes
See full Original NES Game rankings →Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
The Real Debate
Metroid plunges players into a dense, dark sci-fi universe, while Super Mario Bros. delivers a bright, whimsical fantasy world. This battle isn't just about what defines an iconic NES game, it's a clash of atmospheres and legacies with fans fiercely defending their favorite. On one side, the eerie and explorative depths of Metroid challenge gamers who crave rich, narrative-driven experiences. On the other, the cheerful, straightforward platforming of Mario has charmed countless players with its simplicity and joy. Which classic holds your allegiance? Dive in and decide which legacy you champion!
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Super Mario Bros. over Metroid when it comes to the greatest Original NES Games of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Super Mario Bros. 92.5% of the time over Metroid.
Across all battles:
Super Mario Bros. win rate: 84.1%
Metroid win rate: 39.1%
Fan FAQs
Why is the matchup between Super Mario Bros. and Metroid such a big debate among fans?
This matchup hits hard because it pits pure, joyful platforming against dark, explorative adventure. Fans are torn because both games were groundbreaking in their own ways during the NES era, representing different but equally compelling approaches to gaming.
What keeps Metroid so beloved even if it's trailing in fan votes?
Fans adore Metroid for its atmospheric exploration and the thrill of discovering new areas and secrets. The game introduces Samus Aran, whose mysterious, lone bounty hunter vibe resonates with those who love a deeper storyline and a strong, silent type hero.
Why is Super Mario Bros. winning by so much in the Greatest Original NES Games of All Time league?
Super Mario Bros. is crushing it because it's basically the poster child for nostalgic gaming. Everyone remembers those iconic levels and sounds, whether they played it as a kid or just know it from pop culture. Plus, it's a game that totally reshaped the platforming genre and gaming in general.