VS
Your GOAT List
Is Jan the surprise dark horse, or will Charles-Haden Savage stamp his enduring charisma on yet another title? In the heart of the Only Murders In The Building Characters league, this duel isn't just about who entertained us more. It's a deep dive into the core of storytelling charm: Jan, with her deceptive complexity and twist-filled narrative, versus Charles, the embodiment of nostalgic gravitas and unexpected depth. What weighs more in the balance of character greatness— the shock of the new or the comfort of the familiar? Your pick might just redefine what makes a character legendary in this storied series.
In this battle:
The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.
Fans are drawn to Jan because of her surprising depth and the twists she brings to the plot. Her character adds a layer of intrigue and suspense that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats, making her a thrilling and memorable part of the series.
Charles-Haden Savage wins hearts with his blend of humor and vulnerability. His role as a semi-washed-up TV star turned amateur detective is both relatable and endearing, making him a fan favorite for his earnest attempts to reconnect with his passions and solve mysteries.
It's neck and neck because both characters bring something unique to the table. Jan's mysterious and complex nature contrasts sharply with Charles' quirky, lead role charisma. Fans are clearly torn, appreciating both Jan's intensity and Charles' lovable persona.