Greatest Music Videos of all time

Bad Romance (Lady Gaga) vs Thriller (Michael Jackson)

Two picks. One winner. No fence-sitting.

The Real Debate

Thriller by Michael Jackson revolutionized music videos with its groundbreaking narrative and effects, while Lady Gaga's Bad Romance brought avant-garde fashion and bold visuals into the pop mainstream. This GoatWars battle pits the king of pop’s iconic, zombie-filled masterpiece against the queen of pop’s theatrical and visually stunning declaration of love and empowerment. It’s a clash of eras, with Michael’s 80s horror charm grappling against Gaga’s 21st-century pop art spectacle. Will it be the classic, almost cinematic storytelling of Thriller that triumphs, or can the daring and disruptive artistry of Bad Romance steal the show? It's your turn to decide which music video reshaped pop culture more profoundly!

Head-to-Head Comparison

Criteria Edge Why
Visual Burn Thriller (Michael Jackson) Thriller set a benchmark with its iconic werewolf transformation and zombie dance, staying unforgettable decades later.
Rewatch Trap Thriller (Michael Jackson) Thriller's captivating narrative and ground-breaking effects ensure it's a video that fans and newcomers alike can't stop watching.
Moment Energy Thriller (Michael Jackson) When Thriller was released, it was not just a music video; it was a global event that viewers awaited with bated breath.
Copycat Power Thriller (Michael Jackson) The Thriller dance became a global phenomenon, repeatedly recreated in movies, flash mobs, and even commercials, embodying true copycat power.
Bad Romance (Lady Gaga) vs. Thriller (Michael Jackson)

Fan Takes

Honestly, each video revolutionized its era—Thriller set the standard, while Bad Romance is a vivid exploration of self-identity.
Bad Romance? more like 'bad decision' if you think it can take down MJ lol. it's just a meme at this point 😂
dude, thriller is like the holy grail of music videos! i still remember watching it on repeat as a kid—pure magic! 🧛‍♂️✨

How Fans Are Voting

Latest battle odds:

Thriller (Michael Jackson): 92%

Bad Romance (Lady Gaga): 8%

Overall battle results:

Overall fans prefer Thriller (Michael Jackson) over Bad Romance (Lady Gaga) when it comes to the greatest Music Videos of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Thriller (Michael Jackson) 86.5% of the time over Bad Romance (Lady Gaga).

Across all battles:

Thriller (Michael Jackson) win rate: 86.3%

Bad Romance (Lady Gaga) win rate: 32.0%

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup in the Greatest Music Videos of All Time league so hotly debated?

You've got two completely different vibes here: Thriller is all about classic nostalgia while Bad Romance brings a modern, edgy flair. Fans are super divided over which style resonates more, leading to a passionate showdown. The GOAT List for Greatest Music Videos of All Time shows where everyone else lands.

What makes Bad Romance so popular?

Bad Romance is iconic for its bold visuals and Gaga's fierce performance. The song captures a raw emotional connection that fans really vibe with, making it a timeless favorite.

Why is Thriller winning by so much?

Fans just can't get enough of the nostalgia and groundbreaking impact that Thriller had on music videos. It's like a cultural phenomenon that set the bar, and people are rallying behind that legacy.

Not done arguing?

Next Music Videos fight, picked for you.

Keep voting →