Greatest MTV Shows of All Time
Jackass or TRL (Total Request Live)

Pick Your Favorite

JACKASS

VS

TRL (TOTAL REQUEST LIVE)
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Can you hear the engines revving at the starting line? It's not just engines—it's the cultural juggernauts of TRL and Jackass, each revving to claim their spot in the pantheon of MTV legends. Here, it's pristine pop culture pitted against raw, reckless abandon. TRL brought the stars from the sky right into Times Square, giving a platform to icons and anthems alike, creating a daily ritual for millions. On the flip side, Jackass thrashed all norms, turning shock and awe into a form of art. What's at stake? It's more than a spot on a list; it's about which vein of MTV history pulses strongest in the heart of pop culture. So, what’s your flavor—slick celebrity charm or the chaotic thrill of stunts gone wild?

🔥 Fan Takes

idk guys, can we really compare Carson Daly with getting kicked in the guts? Different vibes fr.
Jackass is literally just dudes hurting themselves for fun. Genius or madness? 🤔
lol remember when TRL actually made us rush home to catch music vids? pure nostalgia!

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.

Fan FAQs

Why is this TRL vs. Jackass matchup so close?

This matchup is neck and neck because both shows have deeply passionate fan bases that appreciate different aspects of MTV's golden era. TRL fans love the iconic music countdown and celebrity interactions, while Jackass enthusiasts thrive on the adrenaline and outrageous antics. It’s a classic clash of MTV’s versatility that leaves fans split right down the middle.

What makes Jackass so enduringly popular?

Jackass captured hearts with its wild, often jaw-dropping stunts mixed with a sense of camaraderie among the cast. Its blend of humor, shock value, and outright defiance of norms offers a taste of rebellion that fans just can’t seem to get enough of.

Why is the TRL vs. Jackass debate so intense in the Greatest MTV Shows league?

The heat in the TRL vs. Jackass debate really boils down to nostalgia and contrasting show styles. TRL brought music and celebs directly into living rooms, shaping a music video culture, while Jackass pushed the boundaries of comedy and stunts. Fans are fiercely divided based on which style resonates more with their personal MTV memories.