Ryan Succop (2009) leads with 100% of votes
See full Mr. Irrelevant rankings →VS
Your GOAT List
Marty Moore, the 1994 Mr. Irrelevant, and Ryan Succop from 2009 represent a classic clash of old school grit versus modern precision in the world of sports underdogs. Moore, a linebacker, carried the underdog spirit into the heart of the NFL's bruising physical gameplay, embodying the emotional, hard-hitting football of the 90s. In contrast, kicker Ryan Succop brought a methodical, almost surgical, approach to the same title 15 years later, demonstrating that even Mr. Irrelevant can score with pinpoint accuracy when it counts. This battle isn't just about who's more skilled; it's a debate over the evolving nature of talent and perseverance in professional sports. Choose your champ—do you rally behind Moore’s relentless energy, or do you stand with Succop's cool consistency?
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Ryan Succop (2009) over Marty Moore (1994) when it comes to the greatest Mr. Irrelevants of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Ryan Succop (2009) 100.0% of the time over Marty Moore (1994).
Across all battles:
Ryan Succop (2009) win rate: 55.8%
Marty Moore (1994) win rate: 31.0%
Brock Purdy (2022) is currently the top contender in the Greatest Mr. Irrelevants of All Time league. You can check out where all the contenders stand on the GOAT List.
Marty Moore's fan appeal largely comes from his distinction as the original Mr. Irrelevant to play in a Super Bowl. His underdog story resonates with fans who love a good comeback, adding a layer of respect and fondness despite his current standing.
Fans seem to be totally in favor of Ryan because of his unique story of not just making it in the NFL, but really making a mark as a solid kicker. His consistent performance and the fact he's a Super Bowl champ really set him apart, giving him a massive edge in the votes.