Kelvin Kirk (1976) vs Ryan Succop (2009)
Ryan Succop (2009) leads with 57% of votes
See full Mr. Irrelevant rankings →Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
The Real Debate
Kelvin Kirk, drafted last in 1976, faces off against Ryan Succop, 2009's final pick, in a clash of eras and expectations in the Mr. Irrelevant of All Time showdown. Kirk's underdog story from the '70s stirs nostalgia among fans who cherish the grit of old-school football, while Succop's journey resonates with a newer generation that has seen him convert his Mr. Irrelevant status into a successful kicking career in the modern NFL. This isn't just a battle of who's more successful post-draft—it's a reflection of changing tides in fan allegiance and football values over decades. Which legacy will you champion? Cast your vote and tip the scales in this historic matchup!
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Ryan Succop (2009) over Kelvin Kirk (1976) when it comes to the greatest Mr. Irrelevants of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Ryan Succop (2009) 57.1% of the time over Kelvin Kirk (1976) .
Across all battles:
Ryan Succop (2009) win rate: 55.8%
Kelvin Kirk (1976) win rate: 40.6%
Fan FAQs
Why is this matchup between Ryan Succop and Kelvin Kirk so heated?
The debate heats up because it's a clash between a modern day success story and a historic pioneer. Both contenders have transformed the perception of the last draft pick, each in his own era, making fans passionately divided about who truly deserves the top spot.
What's the biggest reason fans adore Kelvin Kirk?
Fans love Kelvin Kirk for his inspiring story and the legacy he created as the very first Mr. Irrelevant. His journey from an overlooked draft pick to a celebrated figure in NFL lore really tugs at the heartstrings.
Why is Ryan Succop leading in the Mr. Irrelevants battle against Kelvin Kirk?
Ryan Succop is currently ahead because he's known for his solid and consistent performance in the NFL, especially as a kicker. Fans appreciate how he turned the 'irrelevant' title into a distinguished career, which really resonates with them.