Kelvin Kirk (1976) vs Ryan Succop (2009)
Ryan Succop (2009) leads with 62% of votes
Latest odds: Ryan Succop (2009) - 67%, Kelvin Kirk (1976) - 33%
Kelvin Kirk (1976) = Community-focused post-career
Ryan Succop (2009) = Longevity with Super Bowl impact
See full Mr. Irrelevant rankings →Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
The Real Debate
Kelvin Kirk, drafted last in 1976, faces off against Ryan Succop, 2009's final pick, in a clash of eras and expectations in the Mr. Irrelevant of All Time showdown. Kirk's underdog story from the '70s stirs nostalgia among fans who cherish the grit of old-school football, while Succop's journey resonates with a newer generation that has seen him convert his Mr. Irrelevant status into a successful kicking career in the modern NFL. This isn't just a battle of who's more successful post-draft—it's a reflection of changing tides in fan allegiance and football values over decades. Which legacy will you champion? Cast your vote and tip the scales in this historic matchup!
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Criteria | Edge | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Career Longevity | Ryan Succop (2009) | Ryan Succop, still active in the NFL since 2009, demonstrates remarkable career longevity compared to Kelvin Kirk's brief professional stint. |
| Peak Performance | Ryan Succop (2009) | Succop's career as a reliable NFL kicker, including setting records and contributing significantly in playoffs, outshines Kirk's lesser-known professional achievements. |
| Impact on Team | Ryan Succop (2009) | Succop’s pivotal role in games, including a Super Bowl win, showcases a more substantial impact on team success than Kirk’s limited professional appearances. |
| Post-Career Achievements | Kelvin Kirk (1976) | Kelvin Kirk transitioned into impactful community work post-career, which stands out more than Ryan Succop's ongoing career without post-sports achievements. |
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
Latest battle odds:
Ryan Succop (2009): 67%
Kelvin Kirk (1976) : 33%
Overall battle results:
Overall fans prefer Ryan Succop (2009) over Kelvin Kirk (1976) when it comes to the greatest Mr. Irrelevants of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Ryan Succop (2009) 62.5% of the time over Kelvin Kirk (1976) .
Across all battles:
Ryan Succop (2009) win rate: 56.6%
Kelvin Kirk (1976) win rate: 41.0%
Fan FAQs
Why is Ryan Succop winning by so much?
Succop's got a solid track record in the NFL, including helping his team to a Super Bowl win. Fans love a winner, and his achievements in the sport outshine the more sentimental story of Kelvin Kirk, making him a clear favorite among many.
What makes this matchup between Kelvin Kirk and Ryan Succop such a hot topic in the 'Greatest Mr. Irrelevants of All Time' league?
It's the classic showdown between old school charm and modern-day success. Kelvin represents the nostalgic underdog story from 1976, while Ryan brings his recent and tangible NFL achievements to the table. The varied appeal between eras makes this a thrilling debate for fans.
Who is better: Kelvin Kirk or Ryan Succop?
Right now, fans are leaning towards Ryan Succop, leading by a decent margin. He's known for his longevity and success as a kicker in the NFL, which really resonates with fans who value consistent performance.