Final Fantasy XIV leads with 55% of votes
Latest odds: Final Fantasy XIV - 38%, Elder Scrolls Online - 62%
Elder Scrolls Online = Flexible exploration, player freedom
Final Fantasy XIV = Intricate systems, vibrant community
See full MMORPG rankings →VS
Your GOAT List
Elder Scrolls Online offers a sprawling, player-driven narrative in the gritty, immersive realms of Tamriel, while Final Fantasy XIV invites players into a meticulously crafted world rich with intricate stories and vibrant characters. This clash isn't just about which game boasts better dungeons or richer loot; it's a fundamental battle between the chaotic freedom of Elder Scrolls Online and the emotionally engaging, controlled narrative precision of Final Fantasy XIV. Fans of each are fiercely loyal, debating not just the mechanics but which game truly feels like home. Every vote is a stand for either a wild, player-shaped universe or a beautifully guided epic tale. Which side are you on? Will you champion the legacy of Tamriel or fight for the heart of Eorzea?
| Criteria | Edge | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Gameplay Depth | Final Fantasy XIV | FFXIV's job system and intricate crafting offer unmatched depth. |
| World Building | Final Fantasy XIV | FFXIV's rich, cohesive lore and expansive worlds surpass ESO's settings. |
| Community Engagement | Final Fantasy XIV | FFXIV's community is famously active and supportive, bolstering player retention. |
| Content Updates | Final Fantasy XIV | Regular, impactful expansions in FFXIV keep the community engaged and the gameplay fresh. |
Latest battle odds:
Elder Scrolls Online: 62%
Final Fantasy XIV: 38%
Overall battle results:
Overall fans prefer Final Fantasy XIV over Elder Scrolls Online when it comes to the greatest MMORPGs of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Final Fantasy XIV 55.6% of the time over Elder Scrolls Online.
Across all battles:
Final Fantasy XIV win rate: 54.7%
Elder Scrolls Online win rate: 55.8%
It's like a friendly rivalry! Both Elder Scrolls Online and Final Fantasy XIV have huge, passionate fanbases that bring their own vibes. People are split down the middle, making every vote feel like a showdown!
Fans are all about the vibrant characters and the emotional depth of the story. Plus, the community events and camaraderie really make it feel like a home away from home.
Right now, Final Fantasy XIV is leading, and honestly, it makes sense. The community's buzzing about its engaging storylines and social gameplay, which totally hooks fans!