home ⟩ Movies & TV ⟩ Margaret Qualley Performances ⟩ Trish in 'Stars at Noon' vs. Sue in 'The Substance'

Greatest Margaret Qualley Performances of All Time
Sue in 'The Substance' or Trish in 'Stars at Noon'

Pick Your Favorite

SUE IN 'THE SUBSTANCE'

VS

TRISH IN 'STARS AT NOON'
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Does the gritty realism of Trish in 'Stars at Noon' outshine the intense drama of Sue in 'The Substance'? This isn't just about choosing a favorite Margaret Qualley performance; it's a battle of narrative depth versus raw emotional power. Trish's survival instinct in a politically charged romance contrasts starkly with Sue’s visceral journey through personal discovery. Here, fans are choosing between the allure of a slow-burn thriller and the punch of existential exploration. What speaks to you more deeply? This decision shapes what we celebrate in storytelling — are we champions of the understated, or do we seek to immerse ourselves completely in the character’s turmoil?

🔥 Fan Takes

I'm just here for Margaret's magic, idk both roles had their vibes 🤷‍♂️
Ngl, Trish's raw emotion hit different, felt that in my soul. Sue's cool but c'mon.
lol why even compare? Sue in 'The Substance' was ICONIC af. Trish? Meh.

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

Fans currently prefer Sue in 'The Substance' over Trish in 'Stars at Noon' when it comes to the greatest Margaret Qualley Performances of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Sue in 'The Substance' 66.7% of the time over Trish in 'Stars at Noon'.

Across all battles:

Sue in 'The Substance' win rate: 73.7%

Trish in 'Stars at Noon' win rate: 35.3%

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup such a big debate?

The debate heats up because both roles showcase Margaret Qualley's versatility, but in very different ways. Sue's complexity in 'The Substance' contrasts starkly with Trish's visceral emotional journey in 'Stars at Noon', splitting the fanbase over which performance shines brighter.

Why do fans love Trish in 'Stars at Noon'?

Fans really appreciate the raw emotion and authenticity that Trish brings to 'Stars at Noon'. Her character's resilience and the intense portrayal by Margaret Qualley have made a lasting impression.

Who is better: Trish in 'Stars at Noon' or Sue in 'The Substance'?

Right now, Sue in 'The Substance' is leading in the fan votes. Fans seem to resonate with the depth and complexity she brings to the role, which might be swaying the votes her way.