Greatest Leonardo DiCaprio Movies of All Time
Shutter Island or The Departed
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
Imagine a dark stormy night where every flash of lightning reveals a different haunting face: that’s the kind of suspenseful tension brewing between Shutter Island and The Departed. Both masterpieces showcase Leonardo DiCaprio at his finest, yet they ask us to choose between the psychological twists of an isolated, eerie asylum and the gritty realism of Boston's criminal underworld. The battle isn't just about which film is superior—it's about what haunts us more: the demons within or the enemies among us? As you decide, consider what you prioritize in storytelling: a psychological spiral or a crime-ridden saga?
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer The Departed over Shutter Island when it comes to the greatest Leonardo DiCaprio Movies of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick The Departed 71.4% of the time over Shutter Island.
Across all battles:
The Departed win rate: 49.7%
Shutter Island win rate: 34.8%
Fan FAQs
Why are fans so drawn to The Departed in Leo's movie lineup?
The Departed wins hearts with its gritty, complex narrative and DiCaprio’s role as an undercover cop. Fans appreciate the film's raw tension and the moral dilemmas Leo faces, which showcase his ability to dive deep into troubled characters.
What makes Shutter Island a fan favorite in the Greatest Leonardo DiCaprio Movies league?
Fans love Shutter Island for its mind-bending storyline and DiCaprio's gripping portrayal of Teddy Daniels. The film's dark, eerie atmosphere paired with Leo's intense emotional delivery makes it a standout, haunting viewing experience.
Why is the battle between Shutter Island and The Departed on GoatWars so intensely debated?
The debate between Shutter Island and The Departed is fierce because both movies showcase Leonardo DiCaprio's intense acting chops in high-stakes, psychological thrillers directed by Scorsese. Fans are split, often choosing based on which plot twist shook them the most!