Greatest It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia Characters of All Time
Frank Reynolds or Uncle Jack Kelly

Pick Your Favorite

FRANK REYNOLDS

VS

UNCLE JACK KELLY
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Who embodies the chaotic spirit of ‘It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia’ more distinctly? In this corner, the unsettlingly bizarre Uncle Jack Kelly with his fixations that border on the grotesque. And in the other, the shamelessly wild Frank Reynolds, whose antics often spiral into the absurd. This isn’t just about who makes us laugh harder; it’s a battle of bizarre charisma versus brute outrageousness. What’s at stake here is the very essence of comedic anarchy that has defined the show. As fans, the choice you make is a testament to what kind of madness you prefer to reign supreme.

🔥 Fan Takes

Frank Reynolds is the GOAT 🐐. Change my mind. (You can’t.)
IDK, Uncle Jack's hands thing is kinda iconic lol but yeah, Frank wins coz rum ham.
honestly how can anyone NOT pick Frank, man's a legend and honestly, Uncle Jack who??

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.

Fan FAQs

Why do fans have a soft spot for Uncle Jack Kelly?

Uncle Jack's obsession with his hands and his awkward presence just cracks everyone up. He's got this unique blend of creepy and pathetic that somehow wins fans over — perhaps it's his sheer obliviousness or those moments of unexpected vulnerability that make him so meme-worthy.

What makes Frank Reynolds the #1 contender on GoatWars in the Greatest 'It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia' Characters league?

Fans just can't get enough of Frank Reynolds! His down-and-dirty style and bizarre schemes resonate with viewers who love a character who's both unpredictable and uproariously funny. Plus, his willingness to dive into any situation, no matter how absurd, really sets him apart in the league. Check out who's leading overall on the GOAT List.

Why is the matchup between Uncle Jack Kelly and Frank Reynolds so evenly split?

It's a nail-biter because both Uncle Jack and Frank bring their own unique, eccentric flair to 'It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia'. Fans are torn! Some love Uncle Jack's hilariously obsessive quirks about his hands, while others can't get enough of Frank's wild antics and no-holds-barred lifestyle.