VS
Your GOAT List
In the realm of 'I Know What You Did Last Summer 2025', the showdown between Tyler Trevino and Julie James isnât just a contest; itâs a clash of philosophies. Picture Tyler, the bold insurgent, rewriting the rules with every move, contrasted against Julie, the enduring favorite whose resilience has painted her legacy across the series. Whatâs at stake here transcends mere fandomâthis battle questions the fabric of iconic status itself. Will fans lean towards the revolutionary or cling to the timeless virtue of survival? Your preference says more about you than them.
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Tyler Trevino over Julie James when it comes to the greatest I Know What You Did Last Summer 2025 Characters of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Tyler Trevino 100.0% of the time over Julie James.
Across all battles:
Tyler Trevino win rate: 57.1%
Julie James win rate: 57.1%
Tyler Trevino steals the scene with his mysterious allure and unexpected depth. Fans are drawn to his complex character, which mixes a troubled past with a brave heart. He's not just a thriller genre staple, he's a character fans love to root for despite his flaws.
Julie James has captured hearts with her mix of vulnerability and strength. Fans love her because she embodies the survival spirit, managing to stay compassionate in the face of chaos. It's her relatable fight through dark times that really pulls the fans in.
It's razor-thin because both Tyler and Julie have resonated deeply with fans. Tyler's charm and Julie's resilience have their own fan bases, making this one a real tug-of-war. Fans just can't seem to pick a clear favorite!