Greatest Heisman Trophy Winners of All Time
Tim Tebow or Herschel Walker
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
Who truly carries the spirit of college football's highest honor? In one corner, Herschel Walker, a paragon of power and poise, who bulldozed through lines and records alike. In the other, Tim Tebow, the emblem of passion and perseverance, whose clutch plays and kneel-in-prayer victories redefined what a quarterback could be. This isn't just about who ran faster, threw farther, or scored more—it's about the heart vs. the spectacle, the silent strength vs. the vocal leader. What does greatness in the league look like to you? Your choice resonates far beyond this arena.
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Herschel Walker over Tim Tebow when it comes to the greatest Heisman Trophy Winners of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Herschel Walker 79.5% of the time over Tim Tebow.
Across all battles:
Herschel Walker win rate: 55.5%
Tim Tebow win rate: 34.6%
Fan FAQs
Who's the #1 contender in the Greatest Heisman Trophy Winners of All Time league on GoatWars?
Barry Sanders holds the top spot in the Greatest Heisman Trophy Winners of All Time league. You can see how he stacks up against other legends on the GOAT List.
What makes Tim Tebow so popular among fans?
Fans love Tim Tebow for his passionate play and the sheer willpower he displayed on the field. Moreover, his off-field charisma and personal story of faith and perseverance tug at the heartstrings, ensuring a solid fan base.
Why is Herschel Walker dominating in the matchup against Tim Tebow?
Herschel Walker is crushing it mostly because of his legendary college football status and massive nostalgic appeal among fans. His fierce playing style and iconic performances have left a lasting impression that resonates strongly with the voting audience.