Fishstick leads with 66% of votes
Latest odds: Fishstick - 84%, Jonesy - 16%
Fishstick = Quirky aquatic adventurer
Jonesy = Iconic battle-hardened veteran
See full Fortnite Skin rankings →VS
Your GOAT List
Fishstick is a quirky, anthropomorphic fish outfit while Jonesy is the classic, everyman soldier - a stark contrast between whimsical fantasy and rugged realism in the Fortnite universe. This GoatWars showdown stirs up a heated debate among fans: should the honor go to Fishstick's bizarre charm that defies tradition, or to Jonesy's iconic status as the backbone of every battle? Each contender pulls at the heartstrings of fans for different reasons, setting a stage where legacy meets eccentricity head-on. As they stand tied, your vote could tip the scales in this clash of titans – who will you champion in the Fortnite Skins of All Time league?
| Criteria | Edge | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Visual Appeal | Fishstick | Fishstick's quirky and unique design stands out more than the standard military look of Jonesy. |
| Rarity | Jonesy | Jonesy, being one of the original skins, carries a certain rarity and nostalgia that Fishstick cannot match. |
| Theme Consistency | Fishstick | Fishstick's design aligns well with multiple Fortnite themes, especially the aquatic and fun themes. |
| Popularity | Jonesy | Jonesy remains highly favored due to his status as an iconic default character in the game. |
Latest battle odds:
Fishstick: 84%
Jonesy: 16%
Overall battle results:
Overall fans prefer Fishstick over Jonesy when it comes to the greatest Fortnite Skins of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Fishstick 66.7% of the time over Jonesy.
Across all battles:
Fishstick win rate: 55.9%
Jonesy win rate: 48.4%
You’ve got Fishstick with all his goofiness versus Jonesy's classic style, and that contrast sparks pretty heated discussions! Fans are totally split; some love the fun side of Fishstick while others swear by the iconic nature of Jonesy.
Jonesy is like the everyman of Fortnite skins, and fans appreciate his versatility. Whether he's a soldier or a casual dude, his relatable vibe really strikes a chord, making him a fan favorite.
Fishstick has this undeniable charm and nostalgia that fans just can't resist. Plus, who doesn't love a fishy buddy fighting it out in Fortnite? His quirky design and fun emotes really have fans hooked!