VS
Your GOAT List
What happens when the master of rapid-fire monologues meets the queen of cool analysis? In the GoatWars’ ESPN Personalities League, Linda Cohn versus Stephen A. Smith is more than just a battle of on-air flair—it’s a clash of philosophies. Linda's pioneering spirit and steady presence contrast sharply with Stephen’s bombastic and polarizing style. The stakes? Redefining what it means to be great in sports broadcasting. This matchup asks fans: What weighs more—the comforting reliability of a seasoned veteran or the magnetic pull of dynamic controversy?
In this battle:
The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.
Right now, Chris Berman holds the top spot! He’s been a fan favorite for decades, bringing both warmth and depth to his commentary. Check out the full rankings on the GOAT List.
Stephen A. Smith's popularity comes from his fiery debates and the passion he brings to every show. His fearless opinions and high-energy delivery make every segment memorable. Fans can't get enough of his dynamic presence and entertaining hot takes.
It's a nail-biter because both Linda and Stephen A. have huge fan bases and iconic reputations. Linda’s longstanding career and genuine sports insight play off against Stephen A.’s bold style and unforgettable rants. Fans are clearly split down the middle, loving each for their unique contributions to sports commentary.