Greatest Dylan O'Brien Movies of All Time - The Scorch Trials or The First Time

Pick Your Favorite

THE SCORCH TRIALS

VS

THE FIRST TIME
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

What does it really mean to be 'the greatest'? In the GoatWars arena, 'The Scorch Trials' and 'The First Time' throw down in a cinematic clash that's about more than just box office scores. It's a tale of survival versus romance, apocalyptic challenges versus the sweet, stumbling first steps of love. This battle isn't just about which movie entertained more, but about which story resonates with our deepest desires and fears. As fans, your leanings either towards thrilling escapades or heartfelt narratives will tip the scales. What will it be: the fight for tomorrow or the heartbeats of today?

🔥 Fan Takes

Still can’t get over how The First Time captured real awkward teen vibes... Scorch, I hardly knew ya.
Bro, The First Time is just superior, no cap. Scorch Trials? More like Bore Trials 😂
Honestly?? The First Time was cute AF, heart all the way!!! But Scorch Trials had that fire... missed opportunity??

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

Fans currently prefer The First Time over The Scorch Trials when it comes to the greatest Dylan O'Brien Movies of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick The First Time 100.0% of the time over The Scorch Trials.

Across all battles:

The First Time win rate: 54.5%

The Scorch Trials win rate: 25.0%

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup between The First Time and The Scorch Trials such a big debate among fans?

This battle is heated because it pits Dylan's romantic charm in The First Time against his action hero persona in The Scorch Trials. Fans are split between preferring his heartfelt or adventurous performances.

What draws fans to The Scorch Trials, even if it's lagging behind in votes?

Supporters of The Scorch Trials love the intense action and high stakes that Dylan's character faces. It's thrilling and showcases his versatility as an actor, which really resonates with his die-hard fans.

Why is The First Time winning by so much in the Greatest Dylan O'Brien Movies of All Time league?

Fans are probably swayed by the movie's charming portrayal of teenage love and the authenticity Dylan brings to his role. It's struck a chord with a wider audience, giving it this massive lead.