Greatest Dylan O'Brien Movies of All Time
The First Time or Saturday Night

Pick Your Favorite

THE FIRST TIME

VS

SATURDAY NIGHT
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

In the realm of Dylan O'Brien's cinematic works, the clash between 'Saturday Night' and 'The First Time' is not just a battle of films; it's a debate over the essence of memory versus the thrill of new experiences. 'Saturday Night' wraps us in the warm, familiar embrace of recurring joys, while 'The First Time' pitches the heady allure of new encounters. The stakes? A claim to cultural dominance as O'Brien's defining narrative. What will fans honor more: the comfort of the known or the excitement of the unknown?

🔥 Fan Takes

Am I the only one who thinks both movies are kinda meh? 🤔 Like, Dylan's cool and all, but these ain’t his best roles.
lol saturday night had me snoring, the first time is elite fr 🏆
The First Time? Talk about feels 💔 Bro, that movie hit different. Saturday Night was cool n all, but no contest.

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

Fans currently prefer The First Time over Saturday Night when it comes to the greatest Dylan O'Brien Movies of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick The First Time 100.0% of the time over Saturday Night.

Across all battles:

The First Time win rate: 54.5%

Saturday Night win rate: 57.1%

Fan FAQs

What makes 'Saturday Night' a fan favorite, even if it's trailing behind in this head-to-head?

Fans love 'Saturday Night' for its unique take and cinematic style. It offers a different flavor, which, while not leading in this particular matchup, still holds a special place in the hearts of its admirers.

Who's the number one contender on GoatWars for the Greatest Dylan O'Brien Movies of All Time?

Currently, 'American Assassin' holds the top spot in this league. You can check out how it stacks up against other Dylan O'Brien movies on the GOAT List.

Why is 'The First Time' totally dominating 'Saturday Night' in fan votes?

Fans are probably swept away by the charming and relatable portrayal of young love in 'The First Time.' Its heartfelt narrative and strong emotional beats just resonate more compared to the experimental vibe of 'Saturday Night.'