Greatest Dylan O'Brien Movies of All Time
The First Time or Love and Monsters

Pick Your Favorite

THE FIRST TIME

VS

LOVE AND MONSTERS
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

What happens when a tender coming-of-age tale clashes with a post-apocalyptic adventure? This is the crux of the GoatWars battle between 'The First Time' and 'Love and Monsters.' Forget mere preference, this matchup is a showdown of narrative complexities — raw, emotional first love versus thrilling, monster-filled survival quests. In the Dylan O'Brien Movie League, it's not just about topping a list; it's redefining which movie resonates more profoundly with our current zeitgeist. Will fans lean into the warmth of nostalgia or the thrill of resilience? Your choice tells a story beyond mere fandom - it's a reflection of what captivates the communal heart in challenging times.

🔥 Fan Takes

idk guys, 'The First Time' kinda has that sweet first love vibe... but monsters are cool too??
Honestly? 'Love and Monsters' is just a metaphor for adulting in 2020. Monsters everywhere.
lol remember when everyone in 'The First Time' was like peak awkward teen?? nostalgia bomb

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup so close?

It’s neck and neck because both 'The First Time' and 'Love and Monsters' showcase Dylan's knack for deeply engaging his audience in different ways. Whether it's the heartwarming charm of a first love or battling creatures in a thrilling survival story, fans are split based on what speaks to their personal tastes or what mood they're in!

Who's the #1 contender on GoatWars in the Greatest Dylan O'Brien Movies of All Time league?

Right now, 'American Assassin' is leading the pack as the top contender in the Greatest Dylan O'Brien Movies of All Time league. Want to see how all his movies rank? Check out the GOAT List.

Why is the matchup between 'The First Time' and 'Love and Monsters' such a big debate in the Greatest Dylan O'Brien Movies league?

This matchup hits hard because it showcases two very different sides of Dylan O'Brien's acting range. 'The First Time' is all about sweet, relatable drama, while 'Love and Monsters' throws him into action-packed, post-apocalyptic adventure. Fans are torn because they get to see his versatility across genres, making it a tough choice!