Greatest Christmas Movies of All Time
Elf or A Christmas Story
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
What does your Christmas movie soul lean towards: irrepressible joy or nostalgic charm? This isn't just a battle between 'Elf' and 'A Christmas Story'; it's a festive duel between unbridled enthusiasm and wistful reminiscence. 'Elf' bursts through the snow with Will Ferrell’s larger-than-life innocence and slapstick glee, while 'A Christmas Story' transports us to the snow-laden 1940s, complete with leg lamps and Red Ryder BB guns. The stake? It's about more than which film tops the holiday watchlist—it's a clash over the spirit of Christmas itself. Does the modern, manic energy of 'Elf' redefine holiday cheer, or does the understated, vintage vibe of 'A Christmas Story' keep holding its nostalgic ground? Your preference might just reveal how you truly celebrate the season.
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Elf over A Christmas Story when it comes to the greatest Christmas Movies of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Elf 53.4% of the time over A Christmas Story.
Across all battles:
Elf win rate: 57.5%
A Christmas Story win rate: 56.0%
Fan FAQs
What's the appeal of A Christmas Story?
A Christmas Story hits that sweet spot of relatable family antics and holiday traditions. Fans love it for its authenticity and the way it mirrors their own Christmas celebrations, plus, who can forget the iconic leg lamp and 'You'll shoot your eye out!' line?
What makes Elf so beloved across the board?
Elf wins hearts with its infectious joy and Will Ferrell's hilarious performance as Buddy the Elf. The movie's blend of innocence and humor makes it a go-to for feel-good holiday vibes, which keeps fans coming back year after year.
Why is the matchup between Elf and A Christmas Story so tight?
It's a real holiday head-scratcher! Fans are split because both movies capture the Christmas spirit but in such unique ways. Elf brings that upbeat, quirky humor while A Christmas Story offers a nostalgic slice of Christmas past. It's like choosing between eggnog and hot cocoa!