Greatest Cat Movies of all time

Puss in Boots vs That Darn Cat!

Two picks. One winner. No fence-sitting.

The Real Debate

Puss in Boots brings suave charm and sword-fighting bravado to the arena, while That Darn Cat! counters with sly detective skills and a knack for suburban intrigue. This epic showdown in the Cat Movies of All Time league pits a swashbuckling hero against a cunning mystery-solver, setting fan bases on fire. Both cats have carved their niches: one as a fairy-tale adventurer, the other as a cozier, slice-of-life puzzle solver. Their current tie in the standings only heats up the debate—will fans lean toward the daring escapades of Puss in Boots or the clever, real-world antics of That Darn Cat!? Choose your champion and cast your vote to tip the scales in this feline face-off!

Head-to-Head Comparison

Criteria Edge Why
Cat Energy Puss in Boots Puss in Boots captures the enigmatic and sly nature of cats perfectly with its charismatic and adventurous main character.
Rewatchability Puss in Boots Thanks to its thrilling plot and memorable characters, Puss in Boots is more likely to keep viewers glued to the screen than That Darn Cat!
Cat Chaos That Darn Cat! That Darn Cat! delivers more of the real-life cat mischief, focusing on everyday antics and troubles.
Heart Puss in Boots Puss in Boots tugs at the heartstrings more effectively with its tale of redemption and friendship.
Puss in Boots vs. That Darn Cat!

Fan Takes

Honestly, comparing these two feels like comparing a classic novel to a meme. Puss is iconic for his charm, while that other cat is just... well, a relic of its time. But nostalgia…”
That Darn Cat? More like THAT DARN SACRILEGE 😂😂 just look at Puss' cute little boots, fr. like he deserves all the love!
Ugh, Puss in Boots will always have a special place in my heart! I remember watching it with my fam and laughing until we cried! 🐾💖

How Fans Are Voting

Latest battle odds:

Puss in Boots: 51%

That Darn Cat!: 49%

Overall battle results:

Overall fans prefer Puss in Boots over That Darn Cat! when it comes to the greatest Cat Movies of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Puss in Boots 72.7% of the time over That Darn Cat!.

Across all battles:

Puss in Boots win rate: 53.3%

That Darn Cat! win rate: 49.6%

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup between Puss in Boots and That Darn Cat! such a big debate in the Greatest Cat Movies of All Time league?

It's a real clash of styles—Puss has that modern, swashbuckling flair while That Darn Cat! embraces a vintage feel. Fans are split, with each side passionately defending their favorite. The GOAT List for Greatest Cat Movies of All Time shows where everyone else lands.

What makes That Darn Cat! so beloved?

People adore That Darn Cat! for its quirky humor and heartwarming antics. It taps into a classic charm that brings back fond memories for many fans.

Why is Puss in Boots winning by so much?

Fans are totally swept up in Puss's charming personality and adventurous spirit. Plus, the nostalgia factor from the Shrek franchise really boosts his popularity.

Not done arguing?

Next Cat Movies fight, picked for you.

Keep voting →