Greatest Brad Pitt Movies of All Time
Legends of the Fall or Troy
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
What happens when epic battlefields meet the rugged American West? In the GoatWars arena, 'Legends of the Fall' and 'Troy' clash, bringing two different eras of Brad Pitt's storied career into the spotlight. One, a raw, emotional saga set against the sprawling Montana landscape, tugs at the heartstrings with its familial bonds and tragic love. The other, a grand spectacle of ancient warfare, showcases Pitt's physical prowess and heroic charisma on a scale that befits a Homeric poem. At stake here is not just a title, but a chance to redefine which cinematic experience resonates more profoundly with our current cultural moods—do we crave intimacy or spectacle? Your preference will decide if gritty authenticity or the allure of mythic grandeur claims the crown in this battle of legendary films.
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Legends of the Fall over Troy when it comes to the greatest Brad Pitt Movies of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Legends of the Fall 75.0% of the time over Troy.
Across all battles:
Legends of the Fall win rate: 51.3%
Troy win rate: 31.0%
Fan FAQs
Why do fans rave about Troy?
Troy is wildly popular mainly because of the grand scale of its storytelling and Brad Pitt's role as Achilles, a legendary figure of strength and complexity. The intense battle scenes mixed with a story of honor and revenge really capture the imagination of audiences who love historical epics.
What makes Legends of the Fall resonate so strongly with fans?
Fans adore Legends of the Fall for its raw emotional depth and the sweeping story of love, betrayal, and loss. Brad Pitt's portrayal of Tristan, the wild-spirited Ludlow brother, really tugs at the heartstrings and has left a lasting impression, making it a favorite for many.
Why is this matchup between Legends of the Fall and Troy so close?
Both movies showcase Brad Pitt in epic roles that really let his acting chops shine, with Legends of the Fall setting him as a wild-hearted romantic, and Troy as a legendary warrior. Fans are really split! Some love the intense drama and sweeping landscapes of Legends, while others can't get enough of the action and heroics in Troy.