Greatest Bob Odenkirk Performances of All Time
Jimmy McGill in Better Call Saul or Dan in The Spectacular Now

Pick Your Favorite

JIMMY MCGILL IN BETTER CALL SAUL

VS

DAN IN THE SPECTACULAR NOW
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

In the realm of Bob Odenkirk's eclectic portrayals, few clash as starkly as Dan from 'The Spectacular Now' and Jimmy McGill from 'Better Call Saul'. Dan, a fleeting yet pivotal character, provides a sharp contrast to Jimmy's sprawling saga of ambition and moral ambiguity. Here, Odenkirk channels breezy charm versus calculated charisma, setting the stage for a classic underdog versus titan showdown. What’s at stake? A recalibration of Odenkirk's legacy — is he more compelling in brief, impactful appearances or in a complex, layered narrative? As fans, our preferences might just tip the scales. Which performance resonates deeper with you — the momentary brilliance or the enduring struggle?

🔥 Fan Takes

lol why even compare?? Jimmy's got more depth in one episode than Dan's whole movie run smh
Dan was cool and all, but nothing beats the layers Odenkirk brought to Jimmy. It's art.
bro, jimmy mcgill is iconic, like he defines a whole era 😂

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.

Fan FAQs

Why do fans love Dan in The Spectacular Now?

Fans really connect with Dan’s role as a compassionate and wise father figure. It’s a quieter, more subtle performance from Odenkirk, showing his ability to command a scene without the flamboyance of his other characters. His portrayal adds a heartfelt layer to the film that resonates with many viewers.

What makes Jimmy McGill in Better Call Saul so popular among fans?

Jimmy McGill, aka Saul Goodman, is a fan favorite due to his sharp wit, moral complexity, and the depth Odenkirk brings to the role. His transformation from a struggling lawyer into the morally ambiguous Saul Goodman keeps fans captivated and debating his choices at every turn.

Why is this matchup between Dan in The Spectacular Now and Jimmy McGill in Better Call Saul so close?

It's a nail-biter because both roles showcase Bob Odenkirk’s range brilliantly, though in very different ways. Dan’s quiet, supportive nature contrasts sharply with Jimmy's complex, charismatic personality. Fans are split, each side pulling for their favorite portrayal of Odenkirk’s talent.