VS
Your GOAT List
Is it more revolutionary to manipulate minds or to liberate them? This is the heart of the clash between Matt from 'White Christmas' and Yorkie from 'San Junipero'. Matt's dark mastery of psychological manipulation contrasts starkly against Yorkie’s liberation through virtual reality — a classic showdown of control versus freedom. What's at stake here is not just a spot on the all-time list but a cultural verdict on the deeper allure of Black Mirror: do we lean into its warnings, or escape to its utopias? Your preference will echo what you see in the mirror.
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Matt from 'White Christmas' over Yorkie from 'San Junipero' when it comes to the greatest Black Mirror Characters of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Matt from 'White Christmas' 81.8% of the time over Yorkie from 'San Junipero'.
Across all battles:
Matt from 'White Christmas' win rate: 67.6%
Yorkie from 'San Junipero' win rate: 35.7%
The face-off between Matt and Yorkie is a classic clash of thematic depth versus emotional impact. Matt's sinister role in a tech nightmare contrasts sharply with Yorkie's heartwarming journey through love and acceptance in a digital paradise. Fans are definitely drawn to the stark differences in their stories and the broader implications of their episodes.
Matt's dominant lead in the votes comes down to his intense and chilling portrayal of manipulation and the dark side of tech. His character struck a nerve with viewers, sticking in their minds long after the episode ended, which clearly shows in his overwhelming fan support.
In the Greatest Black Mirror Characters league on GoatWars, Matt is clearly leading right now. Fans seem to gravitate towards his complex, morally gray character that really makes you think about the consequences of technology and isolation.