Greatest Benedict Cumberbatch Performances of All Time
Colonel Mackenzie in '1917' or Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
Can the stoic resilience of Colonel Mackenzie in '1917' stand against the cerebral charisma of Sherlock Holmes in 'Sherlock'? This isn’t just a showdown between two of Benedict Cumberbatch's striking performances; it's a clash of philosophies. In one corner, Mackenzie's wartime gravity pulls at the heartstrings of historical drama lovers. In the opposite corner, Sherlock’s razor-sharp wit and modern flair captivate those who lean towards intellectual puzzles and contemporary settings. What’s at stake? A reshaping of which performance defines Cumberbatch's legacy. Which weighs more heavily on the scales of greatness: a compelling snapshot of valor or a complex tapestry of deduction?
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock over Colonel Mackenzie in '1917' when it comes to the greatest Benedict Cumberbatch Performances of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock 57.1% of the time over Colonel Mackenzie in '1917'.
Across all battles:
Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock win rate: 75.7%
Colonel Mackenzie in '1917' win rate: 37.6%
Fan FAQs
Why do fans appreciate Colonel Mackenzie in '1917'?
Colonel Mackenzie's role in '1917' may have been brief, but it packed a punch. Fans appreciate how Cumberbatch conveyed a deep sense of urgency and authority that was crucial to the film's high-stakes, real-time drama. His performance added a significant weight to an already intense narrative.
What makes Sherlock Holmes from 'Sherlock' so beloved among fans?
Sherlock Holmes is a fan favorite mainly because of how Cumberbatch brought a fresh intensity and modern quirks to an iconic character. His performance made Sherlock not just a brilliant detective but a complex, somewhat enigmatic hero that resonated with a contemporary audience.
Why is the matchup between Colonel Mackenzie in '1917' and Sherlock Holmes in 'Sherlock' so intense?
It's a clash of titans! Colonel Mackenzie's stellar but brief role showcased a different, more understated side of Cumberbatch's acting prowess, while Sherlock, a role he played over multiple seasons, became iconic for his quirky, sharp-witted portrayal. Fans are torn because both roles highlight such diverse skills.