Greatest Benedict Cumberbatch Performances of All Time
Colonel Mackenzie in '1917' or Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
Are we in the trenches of 1917 or the mind-palace of Sherlock Holmes? Today’s GoatWars matchup isn't just a battle of Benedict Cumberbatch’s finest; it's a riveting clash of eras and ethos. In one corner, the stoic, war-hardened Colonel Mackenzie, whose brief yet poignant presence in '1917' captured the relentless, gritty spirit of war. In the other, the eccentric, brilliant detective Sherlock Holmes, a character that redefined modern television with his sharp wit and complex psyche. What's at stake? It’s more than just bragging rights; it's about which performance has etched a deeper, more enduring mark in our cultural memory. Will fans lean towards the stark realism of wartime leadership or the intricate puzzles of London’s greatest detective? Your preferences will decide where history leans.
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock over Colonel Mackenzie in '1917' when it comes to the greatest Benedict Cumberbatch Performances of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock 57.1% of the time over Colonel Mackenzie in '1917'.
Across all battles:
Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock win rate: 75.0%
Colonel Mackenzie in '1917' win rate: 37.5%
Fan FAQs
Why is this matchup such a big debate in the Greatest Benedict Cumberbatch Performances of All Time league?
This battle is intense because it pits Sherlock's sharp-witted, modern detective against Mackenzie's stoic, war-time leader. Fans are split over Benedict's versatility, debating between his captivating lead role charisma and his profound supporting character impact.
What makes Colonel Mackenzie in '1917' so popular despite trailing?
Colonel Mackenzie's role, though brief, is incredibly impactful. Fans appreciate how Benedict delivered a powerful and commanding presence, capturing the urgency and emotion of the wartime scenario.
Why is Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock leading against Colonel Mackenzie in '1917'?
Fans are really vibing with Sherlock Holmes because of Benedict's quirky, intense depiction of the detective. His performance not only captured hearts but brought a fresh charisma to the iconic character, making it a fan favorite in this matchup.