VS
Your GOAT List
Is it more tantalizing to watch a villain who wears their heart on their sleeve or one who cloaks it in mystery? In the ring of Bachelor(ette) Villain lore, Luke Parker and Kelsey Poe epitomize this clash of deception and raw emotion. Parker, with his unyielding confidence, often seemed more knight than knave, clashing with the vulnerable, champagne-fueled candidness of Poe. At stake is not just a spot on the GOAT list but the essence of what makes a true reality TV villain — manipulation dressed as forthrightness or chaos spun as authenticity. How do you, the viewers, value your villains?
In this battle:
The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.
Kelsey Poe captured the audience's attention with her emotional unpredictability and the unforgettable 'champagne gate' episode. Her unique blend of vulnerability and drama makes her a compelling figure in the villain roster.
Fans are drawn to Luke Parker because of his boldness and the undeniable impact he had on his season. His confidence and the drama he stirred up make him a memorable villain, and many fans love to hate him!
It's all about the drama they brought to their respective seasons! Luke's intense personality and Kelsey's infamous 'champagne gate' incident offer fans plenty to debate about. It's a classic clash of different types of reality TV villainy, which keeps fans fiercely divided on who deserves the top spot.