Two legends. One pick. No fence-sitting.
Johnny Bench redefined the catcher's role in baseball with his unmatched defensive skills and power-hitting, while Nicklas Lidström set the gold standard for NHL defensemen with his strategic play and consistency. This battle pits raw, dynamic baseball prowess against icy, calculated hockey mastery, each wearing the legendary No. 5. Fans are fiercely divided, as Bench embodies the soul of classic baseball, and Lidström represents the pinnacle of hockey intelligence. As the voting deadlock shows, choosing between Bench’s explosive impact and Lidström’s cool dominance isn’t just about sport—it’s about what kind of greatness resonates with you. Who defines the spirit of the No. 5 for you? Cast your vote now!
| Criteria | Edge | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Owned the Number | Nicklas Lidström | Lidström is often synonymized with No. 5 in hockey, creating a lasting legacy that's hard to top. |
| Peak | Johnny Bench | At his peak, Bench redefined the catcher position in baseball, making him a formidable force. |
| Big Moments | Johnny Bench | Bench's clutch performances in two World Series wins underscore his dominance in crucial games. |
| Aura | Nicklas Lidström | Lidström's presence on the ice amplified the mystique of No. 5, making it iconic within the NHL. |
Latest battle odds:
Nicklas Lidström: 67%
Johnny Bench: 33%
Overall battle results:
Overall fans prefer Johnny Bench over Nicklas Lidström when it comes to the greatest Athletes to Wear No. 5 of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Johnny Bench 93.8% of the time over Nicklas Lidström.
Across all battles:
Johnny Bench win rate: 60.4%
Nicklas Lidström win rate: 40.3%
This debate is huge because you've got Johnny Bench, a baseball icon, known for his powerful presence, versus Nicklas Lidström, a hockey legend with finesse and a different style. Fans are split between sports loyalty and appreciation for greatness across fields. For the full rankings, see the GOAT List for Greatest Athletes to Wear No. 5 of All Time.
Nicklas Lidström is adored for his quiet intensity and incredible skill on the ice; fans remember his leadership and how he set the standard for defensemen in hockey. His consistency and the respect he earned from peers make him a beloved figure.
Fans are absolutely rallied around Johnny Bench, and his legendary status in baseball combined with nostalgic vibes from his playing days have him dominating this matchup. Plus, many feel he's just the embodiment of a true champion.