Greatest Athletes to Wear No. 5 of all time

Donovan McNabb vs Joe DiMaggio

Two legends. One pick. No fence-sitting.

The Real Debate

Joe DiMaggio, a baseball legend known for his grace under pressure, squares off against Donovan McNabb, a quarterback whose dynamic play electrified the NFL. It's a classic showdown between the timeless elegance of a 56-game hitting streak and the raw, unpredictable power of a scrambling QB leading a no-huddle offense. In the arena of No. 5s, each athlete brings a fiercely loyal fanbase, arguing over whose impact and style left a deeper mark on their sport. Will it be the serene king of the diamond or the bold field general who redefined grit? Cast your vote and tip the scales in this epic battle of legacy versus innovation.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Criteria Edge Why
Owned the Number Joe DiMaggio DiMaggio's legacy with No. 5 is iconic, almost synonymous with his New York Yankees era.
Peak Joe DiMaggio DiMaggio was a powerhouse during his peak, setting records like his 56-game hitting streak that still stands.
Big Moments Joe DiMaggio Joe DiMaggio excelled in the postseason, lifting his team to nine World Series titles.
Aura Joe DiMaggio The number 5 on DiMaggio felt monumental, contributing to his enduring mystique and sports legend.
Donovan McNabb vs. Joe DiMaggio

Fan Takes

I can see both sides, but Joe DiMaggio feels like the eternal symbol of greatness — a timeless icon, while McNabb, well, he had his shot. It's tough.
lol, McNabb had his moments but like, can we not pretend he’s on DiMaggio's level? it's like comparing a cat to a lion 😂🔥
man, remember watching DiMaggio play? pure magic! McNabb was cool n all, but Joe was a legend for a reason 😍⚾️

How Fans Are Voting

Latest battle odds:

Joe DiMaggio: 86%

Donovan McNabb: 14%

Overall battle results:

Overall fans prefer Joe DiMaggio over Donovan McNabb when it comes to the greatest Athletes to Wear No. 5 of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Joe DiMaggio 94.4% of the time over Donovan McNabb.

Across all battles:

Joe DiMaggio win rate: 91.6%

Donovan McNabb win rate: 34.6%

Fan FAQs

Who is the #1 contender on GoatWars in this league?

Even with a huge lead, Joe DiMaggio is the top contender, and it's not hard to see why fans have rallied behind him. The GOAT List for Greatest Athletes to Wear No. 5 of All Time shows where everyone else lands.

What makes Donovan McNabb so popular?

McNabb's charisma and strong leadership on the field won him a ton of fans, especially during his time with the Eagles. People love rooting for a guy who stood out in a tough position and always seemed to give it his all.

Why is Joe DiMaggio winning by so much?

Fans are totally swept up in DiMaggio's legendary status and nostalgia for his incredible career. Plus, he represents a golden era of baseball that really tugs at heartstrings!

Not done arguing?

Next Athletes to Wear No. 5 fight, picked for you.

Keep voting →