Simone Biles leads with 53% of votes
See full rankingsVS
Your GOAT List
Imagine, if you will, a scenario where two Olympic titans, each from a different epoch, meet at the crossroads of greatness. On one path, Jim Thorpe—multi-sport maestro of the early 20th century, a symbol of raw, versatile athletic prowess. On the other, Simone Biles, modern gymnastics' dynamo whose airborne twists and turns redefine what the human body can achieve. This isn’t just about medals; it’s a showdown between the traditional grit and the sparkling finesse that have shaped American Olympic lore. Which legacy resonates more with you? Does the stoic versatility of Thorpe triumph, or does the innovative, boundary-pushing brilliance of Biles capture your spirit? Their destinies are in your hands.
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Simone Biles over Jim Thorpe when it comes to the greatest American Olympians of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Simone Biles 53.8% of the time over Jim Thorpe.
Across all battles:
Simone Biles win rate: 62.2%
Jim Thorpe win rate: 59.6%
The top spot belongs to Michael Phelps, known for his incredible records and Olympic medal tally. He's a legend in the world of swimming and on the global stage. Check him out on the GOAT List!
Simone Biles is a powerhouse in gymnastics, known for pushing the boundaries of what's possible. Her charisma, her advocacy for athletes' mental health, and her comeback stories add layers to her appeal. Fans love her not just for her medals, but for her courage and relatability.
Fans are really split over this one! Jim Thorpe's all-around athletic prowess resonates with older generations, while Simone Biles' jaw-dropping gymnastics skills captivate younger fans. Both have left huge marks on their sports and on American culture, which makes deciding a really tough call.