Greatest American Olympians of All Time
Jim Thorpe or Michael Phelps
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
Who defines American Olympic greatness—Jim Thorpe, the versatile legend of early 20th-century sports, or Michael Phelps, the most decorated Olympian of all time? Here lies a classic narrative of tradition versus innovation. Thorpe, a symbol of raw, multi-sport talent, embodies the early spirit of the Games. Phelps represents the epitome of modern Olympic dominance, with a precision-honed skill in the pool. What's at stake? It's more than medals; it's about how we remember and honor our heroes. Which legacy resonates more with you—the foundational hero or the serial record-breaker?
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.
Fan FAQs
What draws fans so strongly to Michael Phelps?
Phelps's unrivaled 23 gold medals resonate deeply with fans who value peak performance and record-breaking achievements. His comeback stories and resilience in the face of challenges also add a layer of depth to his appeal that transcends sport.
Why is this matchup between Jim Thorpe and Michael Phelps so intensely debated among fans?
This is a classic clash of eras and sports, bringing together two different types of Olympic greatness. Thorpe dazzled in the early 20th century with his multisport talent, while Phelps became synonymous with excellence in the pool in the modern era. Fans are torn because each athlete redefined Olympic success in his time.
Who's the bigger legend in American Olympian history, Jim Thorpe or Michael Phelps?
It's neck and neck! Fans are split right down the middle with this one. Jim Thorpe, with his all-around athletic prowess, appeals to those who love a versatile competitor. Meanwhile, Michael Phelps, the 'Baltimore Bullet,' has a legion of followers who admire his sheer dominance in swimming.