Greatest American Olympians of All Time
Katie Ledecky or Jim Thorpe
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
What happens when a turn-of-the-century decathlete clashes with a modern-day swimming sensation? Jim Thorpe, a man who conquered pentathlon and decathlon in the 1912 Olympics, symbolizes the rugged, raw roots of athletic prowess. Katie Ledecky, on the flip side, represents the ultra-specialized, record-shattering era of contemporary sports. This isn't just a contest of eras; it's a crucible testing what we treasure in our heroes — the versatile legend of yesteryears or the hyper-focused champions of today. As fans, your preference will steer the narrative of greatness. Which legacy resonates more with you?
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Jim Thorpe over Katie Ledecky when it comes to the greatest American Olympians of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Jim Thorpe 60.0% of the time over Katie Ledecky.
Across all battles:
Jim Thorpe win rate: 59.3%
Katie Ledecky win rate: 53.6%
Fan FAQs
Why is this Greatest American Olympians matchup between Jim Thorpe and Katie Ledecky such a big debate?
The debate is heated because it pits an early 20th-century all-around athlete, Jim Thorpe, against modern swimming legend Katie Ledecky, highlighting a clash of eras and sports. Fans are torn, appreciating Thorpe's pioneering impact and Ledecky's modern-day dominance in her discipline.
What makes Katie Ledecky so popular among fans?
Katie Ledecky is a fan favorite for her dominance in the pool and her humble yet fierce competitive spirit. Her multiple world records and consistent performances at the Olympics have earned her a special place in the hearts of swimming enthusiasts and sports fans alike.
Why is Jim Thorpe leading in the vote against Katie Ledecky?
Jim Thorpe's lead in the battle against Katie Ledecky comes from his iconic status in multiple sports and his historic Olympic achievements early in the 20th century. Fans admire his versatility and the narrative of overcoming adversity, which continues to resonate strongly.